Which of the following scenarios would give you MOST CONCERN that
the patient
lacked capacity to consent for the given procedure?
a) A 51-year-old understands the risks of delaying the surgery for
her aggressive
bowel cancer but still maintains that she does not want an
operation that may
cure her
b) For the fourth successive time a 63-year-old agrees to have
surgery for a large
incarcerated inguinal hernia, but on arriving in the anaesthetic
room panics at the
thought of the anaesthetic and refuses to have the operation
c) A 38-year-old woman who is 16 weeks pregnant with worsening
signs and
symptoms of acute appendicitis has the risks and benefits of surgery including the
risks to the foetus explained. She refuses to have surgery as she
believes any
medicines, including anaesthetics, may damage her baby
d) An 87-year-old with mild dementia who is conversational and
orientated but prone
to being forgetful asks you twice to repeat the risks you have
explained to him about
the anaesthetic for his dynamic hip screw surgery
e) A 24-year-old with depression thought to be at high risk of
suicide who has
benefited from electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) in the past, refuses ECT
against the
recommendations of two senior psychiatrists. Six months earlier,
the patient, during
a period when considered by her mental health team to be of sound
mind, had
legally signed an advanced directive stating that she did not wish
to ever have ECT
again